Division 5B: Grading Every QB – FlagPlus Football League

Ducks – Antoine Chabot

Grade: A+
8 GP, 191 ATT, 122 COMP, 1,430 YDS, 35 TD, 4 INT, 2 SK, 63.9% COMP, 11.7 YDS/PASS, 117.4 QB Rating

✅ Why A+?

Undefeated team (8-0-0)
Top-tier efficiency: 35 TDs to just 4 INTs
League-high 11.7 yards per comp
Minimal sacks (2), excellent awareness
Highest QB rating (117.4) in the league

🔴 Weaknesses: None. Chabot is the most complete QB this season.

Pasta Arrabiat – Nic Delisi

Grade: A-
7 GP, 199 ATT, 126 COMP, 1,053 YDS, 28 TD, 7 INT, 6 SK, 63.3% COMP, 8.4 YDS/PASS, 101.8 QB Rating

✅ Why A-?

7-1 team record (great but not undefeated)
Solid 63.3% completion rate
28 TDs in 7 games is strong production

🔴 Weaknesses:

7 INTs is a little high compared to top-tier QBs
Yards per completion (8.4) is lower than the elite QBs

Delisi has been excellent but not quite dominant. Still, he’s a reason his team is 7-1.

Gooners – Noah Lieblein

Grade: A+
7 GP, 180 ATT, 120 COMP, 1,059 YDS, 29 TD, 5 INT, 8 SK, 66.7% COMP, 8.8 YDS/PASS, 110.2 QB Rating

✅ Why A+?

Undefeated (7-0-0), perfect record
Incredible accuracy (66.7% completion rate, highest among top teams)
Very strong TD-INT ratio (29 TD, 5 INT)
High QB rating (110.2) with good decision-making

🔴 Weaknesses:

Yards per comp (8.8) is slightly low

Lieblein is a major reason Gooners are undefeated. His precision passing and smart playmaking make him one of the best.

Big TDs – Max Guenette

Grade: A
8 GP, 122 ATT, 76 COMP, 888 YDS, 23 TD, 5 INT, 8 SK, 62.3% COMP, 11.7 YDS/PASS, 106.8 QB Rating

✅ Why A?

7-1 record, elite level team
Very high yards per comp (11.7), shows he’s making big plays
Low INTs (5) in 8 games is excellent

🔴 Weaknesses:

Only 888 passing yards – much lower volume than other top QBs
8 sacks – means he’s taking some pressure

Guenette is efficient, makes explosive plays, and keeps his team winning. However, his low passing volume keeps him just below A+ level.

Maccabees – Shimmy Cons

Grade: B+
6 GP, 128 ATT, 82 COMP, 888 YDS, 24 TD, 10 INT, 10 SK, 64.1% COMP, 10.8 YDS/PASS, 91.4 QB Rating

✅ Why B+?

6-1 record, still an elite team
Great TD production (24 in 6 games)
64.1% completion rate is strong
10.8 yards per comp is solid

🔴 Weaknesses:

10 INTs in 6 games is a big problem
10 sacks show he’s struggling under pressure

Cons is a very good QB, but the high number of interceptions and sacks keep him from an A-level grade. His team is good enough to cover some of his mistakes.

Studz – Philippe Gélinas

Grade: A-
7 GP, 143 ATT, 84 COMP, 999 YDS, 27 TD, 8 INT, 2 SK, 58.7% COMP, 11.9 YDS/PASS, 96.4 QB Rating

✅ Why A-?

6-2 record – solid team performance
27 TDs in 7 games is great production
Only 2 sacks – best pocket presence in the league
Elite yards per comp (11.9 YPC), meaning he makes big plays

🔴 Weaknesses:

58.7% completion rate is below the elite QBs
8 INTs in 7 games is a little high

Gélinas is one of the best deep-ball passers in the league, but his efficiency could improve slightly. Still, he’s a huge reason why Studz are 6-2.

Les Mangeux de Beignes – Xavier Delisle

Grade: B+
8 GP, 193 ATT, 121 COMP, 1,243 YDS, 35 TD, 10 INT, 17 SK, 62.7% COMP, 10.3 YDS/PASS, 99.2 QB Rating

✅ Why B+?

35 TDs is elite-level production
62.7% completion rate is solid
Strong yards per comp (10.3 YPC)

🔴 Weaknesses:

10 INTs is too high for a top QB
17 sacks – the most of any top QB – meaning he’s struggling under pressure
Team record (5-2-1) is good, but not elite

Delisle puts up elite TD numbers, but he’s taking too many sacks and making too many mistakes under pressure. If he cleaned up his game, he’d be A-level.

Crashout Boyz – William Richard

Grade: B
7 GP, 163 ATT, 93 COMP, 1,017 YDS, 27 TD, 8 INT, 13 SK, 57.1% COMP, 10.9 YDS/PASS, 94.8 QB Rating

✅ Why B?

27 TDs in 7 games is strong production
10.9 YPC shows he can make big plays

🔴 Weaknesses:

57.1% completion rate – lowest among top QBs
8 INTs in 7 games is mediocre
13 sacks means he’s struggling under pressure

Richard is a high-risk, high-reward QB. He makes big plays, but his efficiency isn’t great. He needs to complete more passes and avoid pressure better.

Les Super Turbo Navets – Raphaël Caron

Grade: B
8 GP, 189 ATT, 120 COMP, 1,222 YDS, 32 TD, 11 INT, 18 SK, 63.5% COMP, 10.2 YDS/PASS, 97.3 QB Rating

✅ Why B?

32 TDs is an elite total
63.5% completion rate is very solid
10.2 YPC is a great number for a passer

🔴 Weaknesses:

11 INTs is way too many
18 sacks is one of the worst totals in the league

Caron is a talented QB with great stats, but he turns the ball over too much and takes too many sacks. He’s slightly holding back a strong offense from being truly elite.

Dragon Magique – Émile Bolullo

Grade: A
8 GP, 228 ATT, 134 COMP, 1,317 YDS, 36 TD, 10 INT, 9 SK, 58.8% COMP, 9.8 YDS/PASS, 96.4 QB Rating

✅ Why A?

League leader in TDs (36), elite production
Strong total yardage (1,317 yards in 8 games)

🔴 Weaknesses:

Completion rate (58.8%) is below the top passers
10 INTs is too high
Team record (4-3-1) isn’t as good as the QBs ahead of him

Bolullo has great production, but his team record and efficiency could be slightly better. Still, he’s one of the most dangerous in the league.

Dirty Dogs – Jacob Soles

Grade: B-
7 GP, 156 ATT, 82 COMP, 915 YDS, 25 TD, 10 INT, 12 SK, 52.6% COMP, 11.2 YDS/PASS, 83.2 QB Rating

✅ Why B-?

25 TDs in 7 games is solid production
11.2 yards per comp is strong – he takes deep shots

🔴 Weaknesses:

52.6% completion rate – one of the lowest among starting QBs
10 INTs – not terrible but not great
12 sacks show he’s struggling under pressure

Soles has put up decent numbers, but his efficiency is lacking. The low completion rate and sacks prevent him from being higher.

Demons – Alexis Jasmin

Grade: B
6 GP, 117 ATT, 69 COMP, 816 YDS, 18 TD, 5 INT, 8 SK, 59.0% COMP, 11.8 YDS/PASS, 102.1 QB Rating

✅ Why B?

Strong 11.8 yards per attempt – one of the best in the league
Only 5 INTs in 6 games – good decision-making
Team is competitive at 4-3-0

🔴 Weaknesses:

Only 816 passing yards in 6 games – low volume
8 sacks – a bit high considering his pass attempts

Jasmin has played well but isn’t putting up huge numbers. He’s efficient and avoids mistakes, but he needs to be more productive to push into the A-range.

Mighty Ducks – Pranav Sharma

Grade: C+
8 GP, 185 ATT, 81 COMP, 989 YDS, 25 TD, 13 INT, 16 SK, 43.8% COMP, 12.2 YDS/PASS, 71.1 QB Rating

✅ Why C+?

25 TDs is great production
12.2 yards per comp – highest in this group, shows big-play ability

🔴 Weaknesses:

43.8% completion rate – one of the worst in the division
13 INTs – too many turnovers
16 sacks – means he’s struggling to make quick decisions

Sharma is the definition of boom-or-bust. He throws a lot of TDs, but his efficiency is terrible, and he takes too many sacks. If he cleaned up his game, he’d be much higher.

Bullshigh – Matis Sardinha

Grade: C
7 GP, 163 ATT, 81 COMP, 972 YDS, 21 TD, 7 INT, 9 SK, 49.7% COMP, 12.0 YDS/PASS, 90.0 QB Rating

✅ Why C?

21 TDs is decent, though not elite
12.0 YPC shows he can stretch the field
Only 7 INTs – solid decision-making

🔴 Weaknesses:

49.7% completion rate is too low
Team record (4-4-0) shows inconsistency

Sardinha has some good traits, but his low completion percentage keeps him at average. He’s not making enough high-percentage throws.

No Punt Intented – Julien Clément

Grade: C
6 GP, 69 ATT, 36 COMP, 477 YDS, 14 TD, 7 INT, 4 SK, 52.2% COMP, 13.3 YDS/PASS, 74.4 QB Rating

✅ Why C?

14 TDs in 6 games is decent production
13.3 YPC – highest among QBs, meaning he takes deep shots

🔴 Weaknesses:

Only 69 pass attempts – he’s barely throwing the ball
52.2% completion rate is low
7 INTs is too many for his low pass volume

Clément is an interesting case. He’s throwing deep and getting big plays, but he’s not passing enough to have a major impact. He’s a QB that takes shots but isn’t relied upon to carry the offense.

Sleeping Nobody – Slimani Mohamed Ali

Grade: C+
8 GP, 109 ATT, 75 COMP, 821 YDS, 23 TD, 14 INT, 8 SK, 68.8% COMP, 10.9 YDS/PASS, 90.8 QB Rating

✅ Why C+?

68.8% completion rate is the best of this group
23 TDs in 8 games is solid production
10.9 yards per comp shows he can move the ball well

🔴 Weaknesses:

14 INTs is way too high – one of the worst among all QBs
Team record (4-5-0) isn’t great

Ali has accuracy and production, but his turnovers are out of control. If he cut his INTs in half, he’d be much higher.

Sour Puss – Franco Russo

Grade: B
6 GP, 158 ATT, 96 COMP, 1,008 YDS, 22 TD, 4 INT, 13 SK, 60.8% COMP, 10.5 YDS/PASS, 108.3 QB Rating

✅ Why B?

22 TDs to just 4 INTs – excellent decision-making
60.8% completion rate is solid
108.3 QB rating is among the best in this tier

🔴 Weaknesses:

13 sacks in 6 games means he struggles under pressure
Team record (3-3-0) is average – not enough impact to carry them to more wins

Russo is an efficient passer who avoids mistakes. However, he’s not elevating his team enough to push into the A-tier.

Hard Knocks – Tyler Havlena

Grade: C
6 GP, 140 ATT, 75 COMP, 942 YDS, 20 TD, 7 INT, 5 SK, 53.6% COMP, 12.6 YDS/PASS, 93.5 QB Rating

✅ Why C?

20 TDs in 6 games is solid production
12.6 yards per comp is among the best in the league

🔴 Weaknesses:

53.6% completion rate is poor
7 INTs in 6 games is mediocre
2-4-0 team record means he’s not helping them win games

Havlena has playmaking ability, but his inefficiency and team struggles keep him at a C-grade.

Chicken Littles – Viren Patel

Grade: D+
6 GP, 183 ATT, 96 COMP, 737 YDS, 14 TD, 8 INT, 14 SK, 52.5% COMP, 7.7 YDS/PASS, 69.9 QB Rating

✅ Why D+?

14 TDs is okay, considering the team’s poor record

🔴 Weaknesses:

52.5% completion rate is too low
8 INTs is bad, considering the low TD total
14 sacks in 6 games – among the worst in the league

Patel’s offensive line isn’t helping him, but he’s also not doing enough to avoid pressure or make big plays. A struggling QB on a struggling team.

Kicking Assets – Mathew Lamorte

Grade: D
7 GP, 183 ATT, 99 COMP, 974 YDS, 19 TD, 14 INT, 12 SK, 54.1% COMP, 9.8 YDS/PASS, 72.1 QB Rating

✅ Why D?

19 TDs is decent production
9.8 YPC means he takes shots downfield

🔴 Weaknesses:

14 INTs – one of the worst in the league
12 sacks in 7 games – showing he holds the ball too long
1-7-1 team record – he’s not helping them win games

Lamorte is making far too many mistakes and isn’t helping his team compete. He’s putting up numbers, but they aren’t leading to wins.

The Diddlers – Thomas Wright

Grade: D
5 GP, 74 ATT, 36 COMP, 541 YDS, 7 TD, 8 INT, 0 SK, 48.6% COMP, 15.0 YDS/PASS, 65.0 QB Rating

✅ Why D?

15.0 yards per comp is elite – he’s throwing deep often
7 TDs in 5 games is not awful considering the team’s record

🔴 Weaknesses:

48.6% completion rate is terrible
8 INTs in 5 games is bad, especially given his low attempt total
1-6-0 record – not helping his team win games

Wright has a great deep ball, but he is wildly inconsistent. He’s not completing enough passes and is turning the ball over too often.

Les Immortels – Jake Forino

Grade: F
4 GP, 54 ATT, 22 COMP, 144 YDS, 3 TD, 11 INT, 6 SK, 40.7% COMP, 6.5 YDS/PASS, 27.5 QB Rating

✅ Why F?

There’s nothing positive here

🔴 Weaknesses:

3 TDs to 11 INTs is the worst ratio in the league
40.7% completion rate is completely ineffective
Les Immortels are 0-7-0 – his struggles reflect in the team’s record

Forino has had a disastrous season, with more interceptions than almost anyone. His play is actively hurting the team, and there’s no silver lining.

Going out of Business – Pierce Pavliss

Grade: F
6 GP, 113 ATT, 58 COMP, 525 YDS, 7 TD, 7 INT, 8 SK, 51.3% COMP, 9.1 YDS/PASS, 59.1 QB Rating

✅ Why F?

51.3% completion rate is the only thing keeping this from being worse

🔴 Weaknesses:

7 TDs in 6 games is very low production
7 INTs make his TD-INT ratio unimpressive
0-6-0 team record – he hasn’t led them to a single win

Pavliss is slightly more accurate than some of the other failing QBs, but he’s not producing enough to make an impact. This is a forgettable season.

FLAG DEALERS – Roy Khalil

Grade: D+
7 GP, 196 ATT, 116 COMP, 1,092 YDS, 22 TD, 15 INT, 3 SK, 59.2% COMP, 9.4 YDS/PASS, 80.1 QB Rating

✅ Why D+?

22 TDs is very respectable given the 0-8 team record
59.2% completion rate is average
Only 3 sacks means he’s at least making quick decisions

🔴 Weaknesses:

15 INTs is an awful number – second-most in the league
0-8 record – he’s putting up numbers, but they aren’t leading to wins

Khalil is statistically the best of the bottom-tier QBs, but his interceptions are a major problem. He’s not playing winning football despite solid TD numbers.

Momma’s Favourite – Avichai Harrouch

Grade: F
7 GP, 125 ATT, 60 COMP, 526 YDS, 9 TD, 18 INT, 20 SK, 48.0% COMP, 8.8 YDS/PASS, 44.0 QB Rating

✅ Why F?

There’s no way to spin this positively

🔴 Weaknesses:

18 INTs – the worst in the league
20 sacks – the most in the league, showing he has no pocket presence
48.0% completion rate – too low for a competitive QB
0-8 record – the worst in the league

Harrouch has the worst statistical season of any QB. He takes too many sacks, throws too many interceptions, and isn’t completing enough passes. He’s the lowest-graded QB this season.